
Van Gogh, Châtaigniers en Fleurs (1890). Courtesy Sotheby’s.
Sotheby’s will go ahead with tomorrow’s controversial sale of an 1890 painting by Vincent Van Gogh, following an agreement between the work’s consignors and the heirs of its Jewish former owners, who recently claimed that it was sold during Nazi persecution in 1936.
The US-based heirs of German-born Brigitte and Gottfried Bermann Fischer had asked Sotheby’s to withdraw the work from its planned sale of the $450 million Blaquier-Arrieta collection on Wednesday night. However, according to the auction house, “the two families have reached a mutually satisfactory resolution and the work will be sold pursuant to their agreement”.
The Fischer heirs said: “We are grateful for the trusting and fair negotiation and collaboration with Sotheby’s and the Blaquier-Arrieta family, which make it possible to acknowledge the suffering of the Fischer family during the Nazi era and honour Gisela Bermann Fischer’s history of seeking justice for her family.”
The Blaquier-Arrieta family said: “We are pleased to have reached an amicable resolution with the Fischer heirs. We appreciate the constructive dialogue that made this resolution possible and look forward to an extraordinary result and to passing along this masterpiece to a new generation of collectors.”
Van Gogh’s Châtaigniers en Fleurs (1890) will now retain its position as the headline lot of the Blaquier-Arrieta sale. With a $180 million estimate, it will be the highest of any work on the block this season in New York City.
The work depicts blossoming chestnut trees, and it has been guaranteed by Sotheby’s, meaning that its sale would almost certainly set a new record for any Van Gogh painting ever offered at auction. The previous high-water mark for a Van Gogh was achieved by the $117 million Orchard with Cypresses (1888) which was part of the Paul Allen sale at Christie’s in 2022.
According to a report in The New York Times, the Fischer heirs had previously said the painting was sold as a result of financial losses incurred by their family’s publishing company under the Nazis. In recent days, their lawyer, Berlin-based Gunnar Schnabel, had urged the auction house to show that the painting was sold at fair market value and that the family “would have wanted to carry out the sale even without Nazi rule”.
The painting’s former owners moved from Berlin to Vienna in 1936 to escape Nazi persecution. In an email to the house’s head of restitution, viewed by The New York Times, the heirs’ lawyer said that the sale took place three months after the family emigrated, that the Nazis restricted what emigrating Jewish people could take with them, and that the family had been forced to pay a “Reich flight tax”.
Schnabel said that his clients are prepared “to work toward a fair and just solution in the spirit of the 1998 Washington Principles”, the international guidelines on dealing with cultural property stolen or coerced by the Nazi regime and its collaborators between 1933–1945.
Sotheby’s provenance details note that the work was acquired from Brigitte and Gottfried Bermann-Fischer in 1936 by the Paris-based collectors Henriette and Marcel Kapferer through the dealer Paul Cassirer in Amsterdam. Cassirer had had the painting on deposit “since 1932/33”, the catalogue notes.
The work subsequently exchanged hands several more times before making its way into the storied Impressionist and Modern art collection of Carlos Pedro Blaquier and Nelly Arrieta de Blaquier, the Argentine heirs to a sugar fortune. They acquired the work in 1975 from the New York City gallery Wildenstein & Co, according to the catalogue.
Prior to today’s resolution, the auction house said in a statement that it had conducted extensive provenance research into the ownership history of Châtaigniers en Fleurs, but had “not established that the painting was sold under duress”, but acknowledged the importance of engaging “thoughtfully and constructively with the family”.
A respected voice in contemporary art discourse.
Focusing on ambitious storytelling and insightful art-world commentary. Ocula Magazine publishes in-depth interviews, critical essays and timely analysis on the artists, exhibitions and ideas driving the global art world.
Learn more about Ocula Magazine
Showcasing the best of the art world.
Ocula partners with galleries from around the world to highlight their artists, artworks and exhibitions. Gallery membership is by application and invitation, with each member vetted by an independent panel.
Learn more about Ocula Membership
Specialises in the sale of major artworks.
Led by a team with deep ties to the world’s leading auction houses, galleries and collectors. Ocula’s advisory team offers bespoke services to high-net-worth clients from around the world who are looking to acquire the best of contemporary and modern art.
Learn more about our team and services